Friday, 18 July 2008

Judge not lest you be Judged

A friend of mine recommended I read an article in todays New York Times..........
Recommendations like that scare me at times: What point does this person want me to get? Am I getting that point? Is it a message I want to hear?
The article in question is written by David Carr and it talks about his life as an addict and father.

It is a wonderful piece, full of interesting insights and beautiful sentences but the bit I thought I'd comment on is this:

When a woman, any woman, has issues with substances, has kids out of wedlock and ends up struggling as a single parent, she is identified by many names: slut, loser, welfare mom, burden on society. Take those same circumstances and array them over a man, and he becomes a crown prince. See him doing that dad thing and, with a flick of the wrist, the mom thing too! Why is it that the same series of overt acts committed by a male becomes somehow ennobled?

Parenting is hard work; often arduous, thankless, judged by one and all so I'm not here to condemn, we all do our best but I have made a few observations on parenting myself and this single paragraph makes me reflect on each and every one of those ideas over again.

Does this series of overt acts really ennoble a man?
I only know one man who has full custody of his children, he gained custody when his children were aged between about 10 and 15, maybe a little younger, so it was past that time when little children need close and constant supervision, a time when single parenting might be a little easier (?)
I respect this man immensely, not so much because he did the Mum and the Dad thing simultaneously but because he did it without the little courtesies and mercies extended to single mothers. He didn't ask or expect any special considerations for the fact that he was a single parent and while I think that maybe he could have acceptably asked for a little more consideration than he did I was impressed that there was never any woe-is-me attitude. Have I ennobled this man by his single parenthood? Maybe, but I tend to think we expect more of a single father than of a single mother.

I wish that single parents with shared custody would stop whining.
This statement will probably annoy some people and I'm open to discussion but at the moment I see it this way: you have to hand your kids over for a percentage of the time, you might be handing them to someone you don't trust, you miss them when they're away. All of that sucks but please don't talk about how tough it is, especially if the other parent is doing a good job. Parents who are partnered might have support, they might not, but they don't get to hand their kids over for the week, ever. If you have custody for half of the time that's half of the time you don't have to be everything to everyone. It's half of the time you don't have to hound them to eat properly, or do their homework or get to bed or whatever the issue is. That's half of the time you can live however you want.
Don't get me wrong here, I don't envy this kind of situation but it's not "single parenting" it's "single parenting half the time"

Why is a single mother of many children revered if she's getting it right but scorned if she's struggling?
Struggling mothers of one or two are helped, pitied, viewed sympathetically but when there are more kids she is cursed, especially if there is more than one father. Honestly, most of us have met more than one man who we might consider suitable as fathers for our children, is it so inconceivable that someone in different circumstances might actually have had a few kids to a few Dads?
How many times does tabloid TV make examples of struggling young mothers but will step in and present a sob story if the Dad happens to be present? And why is a struggling mother of seven so much more distasteful than a struggling Mum of two?

Single Mums are sometimes better cared for than the rest of us.
If a single Mum has good supportive friends and family half a dozen people are looking out for her welfare but I don't think the same can be said of single fathers and married or partnered women are assumed to be looked out for by their other half, though it doesn't necessarily work that way.
The friends of a single Mum take extra care to be aware of helping out, showing appreciation and generally supporting her, they will make sure her birthday is recognised and that she's given a Mothers Day gift (or two.) No -one makes the assumption that she is okay in the same way that they would for a married woman or a man.


I think we all struggle as parents, I also think we all do our best so I wonder why we don't stop squabbling over who has it the toughest, remember that we can all end up in dire straits with one bad call, support each other because we're really all on the same team, and get on with it.

11 comments:

  1. Kylie, this was thought-provoking in a big way--and yes, one of my biggest pet peeves is the "squabbling over who has it toughest." Yes, parenting is a hard road in some ways, fraught with worry, guilt and sometimes a great deal of self-doubt (you know the good parts, so I won't even mention those!)--whether you have one kid or many, single or married, everyone has their story...

    anyway, now that I've rashly commented, I need to go back and read again and see if I need to hold forth some more!!

    xo

    ReplyDelete
  2. Special,

    What a great post - and I echo what Leah said by saying 'thought-provoking'. I'm not sure I'm really qualified to comment on this, not being a parent - besides, I need to re-read it to form more opinions.
    But for now....

    I think that whether you're a single parent, male or female, or two parents, it is just as difficult either way. I don't believe that raising kiddies is an easy job -lordy knows some of the hell my parents went through! Some people may argue that 2 parents (in the same house) are better than a single parent, and sometimes I have to disagree. Occasionally, one of the parents doesn't pull their weight in the raising of the children and this, inevitably, puts more pressure on the other parent. Also, many of our people are off, out of the country, fighting in wars etc and this, effectively, lends itself to a single-parent family, even though there are 2 parents. I'm not really sure.....those are just my opinions.

    Once again, great post sweetie,
    Peej xxx

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post. I'm going to have to read it several times before commenting (wait, I am commenting!) because it's very complex. I grew up in a big family and the marriage ended in divorce. It's very personal for me, so I have to leave now and compose my thoughts.

    Thanks.

    Oh, and smarty pants, I'm going to write something on the post below. You cracked me up.

    XO Suze

    ReplyDelete
  4. hi guys,
    thanks for your thoughts. i have been wondering if this post (therefore me) has a bad attitude. anyway, i trust you'll pull me up if i'm really out of line :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. This was wonderful. I am not a single parent, but it doesn't make raising my boys any easier. My husband and I have arranged our schedules so that when I am working he is home to take care of the kids and when he is working, I am home to take care of the kids. It leaves us with very little time off together, and even less time alone. We usually don't get to be alone until the boys are in bed. We also, don't have very much support where the kids are concerned. My parents are old and ailing, and the rest of my siblings live too far away to be of much assistance. I do have a couple of neighbors that are wonderful to help, but I had to ask them for help all of the time. But we still manage, we are still happy, and I wouldn't change it for the world.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Kylie,

    You're right about the strangeness of that piece in the NY Times. I can't see how a single parent status ennobles a man. It's unfortunate when women become single parents because the man in their life has abandoned his responsibility. It's also unfortunate when a man doesn't get a fair shake in court when it comes to custody.

    You're absolutely right about the difficulty of "parenting" no matter what percentage of the time one does it. It's about the child, not the parent. Getting a child to eat properly, or do their homework or get to bed or simply to learn to live a life with respect and honor ... is a challenge unto itself. The child will grow into an adult and become a member of society. I fear that people with their own interests are sometimes tempted to overlook the true needs of children for a good quality of life, recognition of their immeasurable worth and personal dignity, and opportunity to become the best person they can be.

    Mrs. Skeeter and I only raised one child. That's all we were blessed to bring into the world. Maybe that makes me especially sensitive to this topic. Thanks for this post. I really enjoyed your opinion.

    Best wishes,
    Skeeter

    ReplyDelete
  7. Well, I don't have to write a single word. Skeeter said it all. Thank you dear friend. Amen.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is the first opportunity for me to have the computer myself for a couple of hours. So I am going to make the most of it.

    Kylie, like the others have said, this a thought provoking post.

    Parenting is not a right it is a privilege and also a responsibilty. Parents be they together, de factos, divorced, or single, are the sole providers of a child's upbringing.

    Like Skeeter, Jo and myself have been blessed with one child.
    Our Helen is an IVF baby and we love her very much.

    Except of course when she hogs the computer :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hello leah, peter, skeeter, suzanne, cecile, and of course, kylie

    Kind thoughts to you all.
    Amen and God bless.

    Mark.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks Mark. Love to your family too.

    Kylie, thank you for your kind words on my blog. They matter a great deal. I won't delete. Your point is well taken.

    Love you so much,
    Suze

    ReplyDelete
  11. hello all,
    as i said earlier i was a bit afraid of grossly offending someone with this post but it seems that you're all ok with it or terribly diplomatic so thanks for your thoughts , thanks for reading all the way through and ...um.....well....i guess i'm finished
    cheers
    k

    ReplyDelete

go on, leave a comment or four.