Stacey Warnecke was a "wellness influencer" who died of a postpartum haemorrhage following the unassisted birth of her first child in Melbourne last year. As the coronial enquiry wraps up I remembered a client I might have had back when I was practising as a doula.
"Bella" was a doula herself and we had met for coffee a couple of times when I had wanted her to be my back-up.
On this occasion, Bella had asked me to meet up and wanted to discuss the possibility of me becoming her doula. She wasn't yet pregnant but was making plans.
Bella asked my opinions about various aspects of birth: whether I would support a home birth, how I felt about unassisted birth and finally she asked if I would call an ambulance if she lost consciousness. I carefully explained that if she was unable to make decisions for herself, that responsibility would fall to her husband as Next of Kin. I also explained that I hoped he would make that decision but if I was concerned enough, I would not be able to stand by and do nothing.
Bella told me she was so against medical intervention that she would rather die than go to hospital. I said that I didn't believe she would hold to those principles when she was actually carrying a baby and the life of that baby was at risk.
Needless to say, I didn't get the job but I did hear through the grapevine that she did have a baby boy after an emergency transfer to hospital.

Bella said she was so against medical intervention that she would rather die than go to hospital!!! I cannot believe that a new mother would risk her own life, but even worse, I cannot believe that a new mother would risk her beautiful new baby. A postpartum haemorrhage cannot be predicted before the labour starts, but once a serious problem arises, only the Nazis would have left the mother without medical care.
ReplyDeleteWhen push came to shove, thr instinct to preserve life kicked in and she went to hospital.
DeleteI'm not sure what would motivate a person to even say something like that.
Sorry for the Anonymous.
DeleteHels
It seems absolutely bizarre to me that a person would be so strongly against medical intervention that she would rather die than go to a hospital. But if somebody truly takes that position, one can only look upon it as natural selection in action.
ReplyDeleteActually the use of a doula constitutes medical intervention to an extent. So does modern hygiene, eating sanitary food, or putting a bandage on a cut. The people who insist on this particular taboo seem to object only when the intervention is above some arbitrary standard of technology.
It was a bizarre moment in my life!
DeleteOne obstetrician ( John H Kennell) said "if a doula were a drug, it would be unethical not to use it" obviously he understood doulas as interventions
When so much help is readily available, not necessarily a hospital, why would anyone choose an unassisted birth? Surely they know that things can go terribly wrong? my four were all hospital births and all grandchildren too, though times have changed between the 70s and the 90s and everything isn't as "clinical' now.
ReplyDeleteYes, unassisted birth is unnecessarily risky. A homebirth midwife will be happy to observe from the background and allow the parents space while having oxygen and drugs on hand if needed
DeleteI feel so old and out of touch. Hospitals are great places to give birth. Why go through a home experience when in hospital you probably have the most lovely staff to care for you and your baby, with your partner there if they want to be. You want to give birth at home? There may be serious consequences from your self indulgent decision.
ReplyDeleteAnd read about home birth history, when most women gave birth at home and many died, and their babies too.
DeleteAndrew, you are far from out of touch. Most people still value hospital birth and it can be a wonderful experience. My kids were all born in hospital but these days I would regard home birth with qualified midwives as the Gold standard for low risk pregnancies.
DeleteBirth suffers the same issue as vaccination in that some of us have forgotten how dangerous illness and birth can be.
Stacey Warnecke didn't have any qualified assistance so nobody recognised how much trouble she was in.
The maternity hospital where I live has closed down and lots of pregnant women are facing a 2 hour trip to a hospital where they can give birth. Some are giving birth in lay-bys - and I think there have already been deaths. It's awful when we're supposed to be living in a modern world.
ReplyDeleteHowever, I was born at home and then my dad knocked over an ironing board and nearly catapulted me out of my cot!
Sx
Two hours seems an awful long way, doesn't it? I would have thought it would make sense to keep a local service.
DeleteYour poor dad! I banged into a doorway and smashed my newborns head. He's 31 now but I still feel bad about it.
Thank you, Ms Scarlet
Oh don't worry Kylie, my third child pulled my fourth one out of the pram onto cement as a newborn and smashed his face up real good. I had left them unattended for a minute to nip in to do a quick wee.
ReplyDeleteNeedless to say, with a split nose, two black eyes and cuts and abrasions there aren't many baby photos. Good story though.
I support all mothers to make their own choices when delivering their babies, but when you cannot use your God given common sense, I do wonder.....
Megan
Oh man! That was no fun!
DeleteI once met a family where one kid jumped from a bunk bed and grabbed a light globe with disastrous results and another broke a bone on the same day. The parents went to two different hospitals for fear of how it looked.
There are some very fringey people with loud voices in the birth world, they can be dangerous.
I've heard many stories of home births without assistance and think it a form of madness. So much can go wrong, both for the baby and the mother. I had both my kids in the maternity unit at Toronto General. Superb care in the days when you could loll about in a hospital for a week or more.
ReplyDeleteXO
WWW
I think i understand why people want to birth unassisted but the final result is an incomparable sense of achievement or an incomparable loss. I know which I'd prefer.
DeleteWhat a silly, silly, stupid, stupid woman, Bella was to say that death for her and, by implication, her baby was preferable to life if staying alive required a trip to the hospital. By doing this, she put you in a situation in which you were expected to watch her and her baby die rather than take steps to save them. I don't know if you would have been legally liable had you done this, but I were a district attorney (maybe they go by another name where you are), I would sure be looking for someone to prosecute. There's a nutty Christian here in Oregon, USA, that sometimes loses a couple of parents to prison because they allowed their child to die of something that antibiotics would have cured rather than seek medical help (of course, the couples always claim that the death was God's will). I can't imagine what such people's non-affiliated parents and other relatives must suffer because their grandchild, niece, or nephew died for nothing.
ReplyDeleteAs you know, my wife, Peggy, was an L&D nurse and sometimes saw patients and their babies died because they used a non-licensed midwife who didn't call for help before it was too late.
Thank you, my dear Kylie for your wise response to my grief-filled letter. I hope I can find the strength to do as you suggest.
Hi Lowell,
DeleteI would have been an idiot to take the job but until that moment I wasnt aware of what direction she was headed.
I think our equivalent of a DA would be the public prosecutor.
While a doula is not medically qualified and theoretically has no medical responsibility, I was warned very clearly that in the absence of anyone qualified, we could be seen as the most expert person in the room and would likely be held accountable.
I continue to wish you and Peggy well.
"She would rather die than go to hospital," That's ridiculous. Yes, hospitals make mistakes, but as Wise Web Woman says, so much can go wrong with a home birth and you need to have qualified medical staff on hand in case of an unexpected emergency. I don't understand those people who are so anti doctors or hospitals.
ReplyDeleteWe need to be clear that a home birth with medical assistance is as safe as hospital for low risk pregnancies. An unassisted birth is a whole different kettle of fish.
DeleteIn this case, I suspect there was some pressure from the "birthkeeper"